98 Wine Spectator
A study on the interplay between finesse and power. Racy acidity and intense minerality drive this seamlessly<br/>meshed wine, while the finely detailed texture and layers of grilled white peach, hazelnut, kumquat and crystalized<br/>honey display overall elegance. Hints of fleur de sel and coffee liqueur echo on the finish. Drink now through 2027.<br/>949 cases made. A.N.
95 Robert Parker
The 2000 Brut Blanc de Blancs Clos du Mesnil is rich, deep, textured and wonderfully complete. The seductiveness of the 2000 vintage comes through beautifully, but the Mesnil has extra dimensions of depth that aren’t found in the Vintage. Smoke, ash, graphite, pastry and lemon are some of the nuances that unfold in this supremely gracious, refined Clos du Mesnil. I expect the 2000 to take some time to reach its peak, but it is superb, even at this early stage. Anticipated maturity: 2015-2035.
95 Vinous
Just beginning to show the early signs of evolution in its color and flavors, the 2000 Clos du Mesnil is in an in between spot where it is ideally cellared for at least another few years, after which it is likely to remain at a plateau of maturity for many, many years. Smoke, crushed rocks, dried pears, spices and chamomile all add nuance as the wine gradually opens up in the glass.